In Defense of Color Commentary

As I said in an earlier post, I’m a permanent judge on SC2GG Commentator Idol, presented in association with Voice of eSports.  My main focus in judging the contestants’ submissions is what’s known as “color” – in commentary, this means essentially things the commentator says that distinguish him or her from a person or computer who’s only analyzing the technical and strategic aspects of the game.  This includes, but is not limited to, analogies comparing what’s going on in the game to situations in real life, fiction, etc. and expressions the commentator uses to convey the excitement of the game.  This approach has generated some controversy over the importance of these aspects in StarCraft commentary, and to that end I composed an explanation for why I think color is a valid judging criterion for Commentator Idol.

Technical knowledge is an extremely important factor when it comes to commentary, but if it were the only factor then anybody with sufficient technical knowledge would be a great commentator. This is not the case. Commentary adds entertainment value to a game, and although StarCraft is more entertaining automatically if you can understand what’s going on from a strategic perspective, there are other ways to increase entertainment value that affect the final product.

I’m a person who doesn’t care all that much about the commentator’s technical knowledge beyond a certain point … if the commentator says the player is going for a 3-hatch build instead of a 9-pool, that’s one thing, but if he says the mutalisk micro was slightly off when really it was that the terran had brilliant turret placement during one particular harass, it doesn’t really matter to me. The commentator can have the best technical knowledge in the world, but if he or she is boring or annoying to listen to, I’m not going to listen.

Color is about being able to make the commentary interesting beyond just saying what’s going on and why in a StarCraft context. There is a world that exists outside of StarCraft, and the two, in my opinion, should not be kept separate. Fundamentally, if you want StarCraft to appeal to a more general audience than just the people who play on ICCup, you have to be able to make StarCraft relevant to the real world – the world of people who have other interests and values that don’t relate to one particular game, and the world of people who want to be entertained. Good color commentary makes the outside world relevant to StarCraft, and in return, makes StarCraft relevant to the outside world.

There are many cases where people use sports metaphors for non-sports phenomena without a second thought. Kissing is "getting to first base" and the working world is called the "rat race." People are often told to "go for the gold" or "keep your eye on the ball" by motivational speakers. It’s firmly established that sports are relevant to life, and part of the reason why that happens is that sports are enjoyed by a large population of people, many or most of whom don’t understand or care about the higher-level technical details of a particular game. If someone who doesn’t understand StarCraft that well watches a commentary and doesn’t understand that a particular skirmish is key to the outcome of the game, he or she won’t understand that fact any better if the commentator just describes it technically. If, however, the commentator says that this particular timing push is like Napoleon going into Russia or like trying to bake a cake without flour, the significance becomes much clearer.

The bottom line is that Commentator Idol is not looking for a commentator who appeals only to diehard StarCraft fans or players. A good commentary should be very technically accurate, but it should also be exciting and leave a first-time viewer wanting to see more, even if they don’t understand exactly what’s going on. Color helps bridge that gap and make sure StarCraft appeals to a greater population and not just those who are D+ or higher on ICCup. Is competitive StarCraft just a niche novelty or can it also be a general spectator sport? Color commentary is a lot of what lets StarCraft make that transition.


Announcing … The PeaPod!

Let’s face it … I’m not cut out to be an SCBW commentator – the game has been around too long and the effort involved to rival the best would be a little more than I could handle with my other activities.  However, I do want to contribute to the community more than just by managing things at SC2GG and occasionally writing blogs or articles, so to that end I’ve started a podcast – The PeaPod!


This episode features a very entertaining interview with a special and elusive guest – check it out!  Leave me feedback for what you want to hear in this podcast as well ^_^.  Next episode out in two weeks!


Commentator Idol!

Hi everybody, terribly sorry for being afk for so long … I’ve had some financial issues and other stuff pop up, but I still shouldn’t have waited so long to write a good article.


One major project that I got drawn into and has dominated my StarCraft life for a few weeks already is the SC2GG Commentator Idol, presented in association with Voice of eSports (the company I started a while back with some SC2GG people) and masterminded by Cholera, the history-loving Reach-adoring commentator who is one of SC2GG’s best-known voices.  I’m one of the two permanent judges of Commentator Idol, which is a parody of American Idol with up-and-coming YouTube StarCraft commentators in lieu of Kelly Clarkson and Taylor Hicks. 

Here’s the first episode – go to the Violetak account on YouTube to see the rest!


I’m the Paula Abdul figure of the show, I guess, with Cholera playing Ryan Seacrest and another well-known SC2GG commentator named Rise attempting to be Simon.  We just released Episode 3: Foreign but Gosu today, and for the last couple episodes we’ve had some really interesting guest judges on the show too – Diggity for Ep 2 and Chill from TeamLiquid for Ep 3.

The Guest Judges (so far)



Diggity in avatar form

Chill, celebrating BlizzCon


The Permanent Judges

Slide1 Slide2
Yes, Rise really is this cool

It’s me!


The Host


No, Cholera is not actually an ungodly hybrid of Reach and Chuck Norris.  This is just what he aspires to be.

What I’ve really been impressed by, though, has been the quality of the contestants who are on the show.  Cholera, Rise, and I went through 17 applications consisting of two commentaries for each applicant in order to come up with the six (originally five but one more slot added because of interest) contestants for the first episode.  So far two of them have been eliminated, and we were very sad to see them go, but this just underscores for me how incredibly talented, smart, and eloquent the remaining four are.

The First to Fall

hamilcaravatar smi1ey_avatar
Hamilcar was eliminated in the first episode with guest judge Diggity smi1ey was eliminated in the second ep with guest judge Chill


The Final Four

KennyPic2 hazel
MFTW parcx-1

If any of you are looking for some fresh new voices in the YouTube commentary scene, I’d highly recommend you click on these avatars and check out the contestants’ YT channels – they’re all excellent in different ways.  And yes, Hazel is a girl.  She’s also a damned good StarCraft commentator.

Anyway, stay tuned for episode 4 – dual commentaries!  Kenny and Hazel are casting two Korean SC mirror matches, as are Morph and Parcx.  The VODs will be listed on SC2GG on Thursday (although they may be up on the contestants’ individual pages before then) and voting will open Thursday evening.  If you’re interested in taking part, sign up on the SC2GG forums and vote!  The judges’ votes count towards the total, but the majority is held by you, the people!

Better Late than Never – Mass Madness 13!

On December 6th, 2008 I went to an awesomely low-key Melee tournament out in Framingham, MA at Game Universe. I look forward to going to more and taking more pictures. Apologies for the picture quality – I’ll get or borrow a new camera for the next one. Stay tuned!

Results (from this thread)


1. Banks and th0rn (Fleshwang)
2. Dazwa and Zoso (The imperialfiendlord imports his water from Athens but is still as Sleepy as Darc)
3. Skler and Pine (Pup n’ Suds)
4. Alukard and GMoney
5. Elen and AOI


1. KoreanDJ
2. th0rn
3. Reno
4. DJ Nintendo
5. Banks
5. Zoso


Let the games begin!



G$ ruins the shot …


That’s better.



Some non-smash gaming, just for kicks





Can you feel the intensity?!



C’mon, let’s hear some trash talk!